diff options
author | Einhard Leichtfuß <alguien@respiranto.de> | 2019-10-18 00:28:00 +0200 |
---|---|---|
committer | Einhard Leichtfuß <alguien@respiranto.de> | 2019-10-18 01:17:39 +0200 |
commit | 4e2ceb9875c81c33b09f6eaf0858b7f9591b22cc (patch) | |
tree | be3860dc8c26b3c18a30c2a81b58e00025b98069 /TODO | |
parent | 51f58d7c4c984ec8ccc5ab0a3d31d04cd39d499c (diff) |
A notable problem (to me) with the former version was, that upon simple
movements in the source file tree, these would in general cause
duplicated data in the backup forest. This problem has been resolved
by essentially tracking file movements, using hard links.
Also, the code has been divided into several different files, extranous
code removed, the organization of remote code execution simplified.
In the process of simplification, all parts requiring direct interaction
of the user with the program have been replaced. In most cases, this
means that the program now just terminates with an error instead of
allowing the user to confirm deletion of an unexpected (remnant) file.
This may be considered a drawback, but actually these interactive
options were anyways suboptimal solutions in most cases - where they
occured, which was due to remnant files of aborted or failed former
backups.
In general, there have been a lot of changes. Which are not thoroughly
documented here. Since there is often no strong relation to the old
code, this is not deemed necessary, as the in-code documentation is
expected to be of sufficient help.
Also, there has been added a little general documentation in the README
and particularly the NOTES file.
It is to be noted that this new version is far from sophisticated. It
has been tested with and is in use for real data, however lacks a lot of
convenience. In particular, if a backup fails unexpectedly, the next
backup will in the very most cases loudly fail without manual
intervention. Also, the program is not able to continue the growth of a
backup tree built with former versions of this program, by itself. This
can however be arranged by hand.
Diffstat (limited to 'TODO')
-rw-r--r-- | TODO | 29 |
1 files changed, 26 insertions, 3 deletions
@@ -1,4 +1,8 @@ # -- BUGS -- # +- /path/ is not recognized as configured, when only /path explicitly is + configured. +- After a failure, the .backup directory is in a bad state (contains backup + data labeled as old, however not related to the destination). # -- TODO -- # - For ssh, set up one single connection (maybe configurable?). @@ -6,13 +10,11 @@ -oControlMaster=yes \ -oControlPersist $remote /bin/true `- ssh -oControlPath=/tmp/root-readable/something.sock -- Replace echo by printf(-functions). - Set up default configuration file. - [consider] When installing, copy the config file to both /etc and /usr/share, such that sourcing from the latter location removes the need to specify default options in the script itself. - Test for read/write access at some point. -- Better error reporting. - Use autotools. - Per dirpath rsync_args. - Allow for resuming of backups. @@ -21,7 +23,7 @@ `- Not a good idea if a notable amount of time passed. `- [question] What happens in case of partially transferred files? `- --delete-during, --delete-excluded -- Shell completion of configured backup paths. +- [consider] Shell completion of configured backup paths. - Better error handling on failure (of rsync). - Use ask(). `- Allow for configuration of default answer. @@ -29,6 +31,12 @@ - [consider] Get date on source host. - Named backups to allow for different destinations per source (and shorter names). +- Test suite. +- Check for several file systems in a tree (and error upon locating such). +- [consider] Add fallback if no local mirror of the source file tree is + available. +- Only store the last mirror locally, but date it. +- [consider] --one-file-system as default option. # -- PROBLEMS -- # - rsync bug: https://bugzilla.samba.org/show_bug.cgi?id=13445 @@ -56,3 +64,18 @@ `- For now, -v or -vv in rsync_args should work fine. - non-intercative option. - rsync_network_options (when remote src or dest, e.g. for --compress). +- Write metadata. +- Use wrappers for the functions possibly non locally executed. +- Compare src:work/$old_date and dest:$old_date for consistency. +- Run script instead of function remotely + `- ssh host 'bash -s' -- < script_file args + `- In case of dependencies, the otherwise sourced files could just be + included in the stdin of ssh. + `- cat script_file dep_file | ssh host 'bash -s' -- args +- Use stdout of functions to return a string value and stderr for everything + else. + `- Optional: Prefixes determining whether normal or error. + `- Convert at the end (remove prefix and pipe to stderr / stdout). +- Only keep the respectively latest backup on the source. + `- Or the last two, which would allow to reuse the second-last as new + mirror (for a probably negligible gain, if any). |